Dev D is the most compelling mainstream movie made in the history of Bollywood cinema. Given this outlandish claim, you know how this entry is going to pan out.
Easy things first. Dev D is a cinematographic masterpiece. The movie has an all pervading hue, which never jars, never intrudes, just vibrantly sets the mood for the drama to unfold. In darkness, the frames burst to life with a richness so deep, that you are almost disappointed when day comes along . Take a look at the scene with shadows and yellow light in which Dev and Chanda are seated after a swim in the pool. Brilliant. Note, this is not Bhansali style opulence. The settings never dominate the scenes. The best shades still belong to the actors.
The writing ranges from the mischievous to the brutally curt, but never wallows in self pity. We are not expected to sympathize with Dev. Hate ?Hmm..too extreme. Indifference? Ya...if we are generous enough not to take this senseless spoilt lout too seriously. Kya chutiya hai bey?, is the predominant emotion. As a matter of fact Kashyap does not want us to feel for any of his characters. Paro, consigned to life with a widower ; Chanda , the wronged prostitute, both seem to wear their destiny with such elan that we tend to rebuke any pity which starts within us. His sole focus is his story and the medium he uses for his narration. It is a brave decision and he gets away with it solely because of the sheer magnificence of his presentation. One of my favorite scenes in the movie is when Paro washes Dev's clothes and then lies inanimate when he tries to make love to her. It is heartless, it is cold; it is the mood of all Dev D.
Dev D is a musical claiming to have more songs than dialogues. Three songs stand out. Emosanal Atyaachar (the bass band version) is one of the most innovatively choreographed songs I have seen. The song and its dance routine almost seems to mock Dev. Pardesi is performed in a bar with three dancers who function as the quintessential observers in the second half of the movie. They watch proceedings with an amused commiserating eye. Lastly Nayan Tarse which just accentuates the brilliance of the scene already mentioned in this blog. The scene in which Paro kicks Dev's sorry ass. This movie is set up completely by its music. The dialogues merely punctuate.
The acting is competent, the narrative is crisp, the encounters among the cast is delightfully saucy and blah and blah and as we soar through the skies revelling in such great cinema, Kashyap brings us back to earth with the final thrity minutes. The movie loses its grip after Dev runs over a few people with his car. I would have ended the movie there and then. There are fates worse than dying. Dev deserves what he gets. Instead, there is an awakening in our lead, he sees the light and gets back to his girl and we are expected to smile on indulgently. Not happening, not happening in a long time. Remember Anurag, we dont feel shit for him.
But all sins forgiven, director. Dev D is one of the most important movies made in Bollywood simply because it is so utterly unapologeticly filmi. There have been greater movies in the past in our country but here is a product we can flaunt uniquely as our own. There is a rich guy and a poor girl and there are songs and there are dances and whats more, it is art at its highest. Bravo.